We’re celebrating a Mill-Made Christmas! The tradition of giving handmade gifts for Christmas dates back to the first settlers of the Smoky Mountains. Preserves that captured the freshness of the season, warmed with spices, made them something special. Pottery hand-thrown from the clay soil of our region created beautiful gifts that lasted generations. Fresh-baked cakes and pies were always a treat for hosts and guests alike at gatherings. Keeping those traditions alive here at The Old Mill is a true labor of love for all of us. As you gather this holiday season, and send gifts to family and friends far away, it humbles us to be a part of your celebrations, and it’s an honor to share our rich heritage with you.
VISIT OUR FAMILY OF BRANDS IN PIGEON FORGE, TENNESSEE
OLD MILL GIFT CARD The perfect gift, every time. Old Mill Gift Cards can be used at the Old Mill Restaurant or Pottery House Cafe, or any of our shops. No expiration, no fees.
DOWN SOUTH breakfast box
Give the gift of a cozy Christmas morning, the Southern way.
HOLIDAY MORNINGS
Biscuits, muffins, and brews made for holiday mornings.
B. NEW! MILLER’S MORNING $39.99
Gift-Boxed & Holiday-Ready Our Head Miller, Chuck, starts each day with a cup of fresh hot Miller’s Morning Blend, and when no one’s looking, he sneaks up to The Old Mill Restaurant for a Banana Nut Muffin or two! Includes a bag of ground Miller’s Morning Blend Coffee and a package of our Banana Nut Muffin Mix.
A. NEW! DOWN SOUTH BREAKFAST BOX
$59.99 Gift-Boxed & Holiday-Ready
Here in the South, breakfast is something we take seriously! It always has to include some of our Stone Ground White Grits. Pralines are a Southern treat, so we’ve included our Pecan Praline Pancake & Waffle Mix and teamed it up with Banana Caramel Pancakes. And to finish it off is a bottle of Roasted Pecan Syrup and some Smoky Mountain Mist Coffee.
C. PUMPKIN SPICE PANCAKE MIX $12.99
The Old Mill has put the warmth of fall flavor in this Pancake & Muffin Mix. The perfect blend of sugar and pumpkin pie spice comes together in fluffy stacks the whole family will love. We also include a recipe for muffins on the back of each bag, so you can add a bit of fall to any meal or snack! Available in a 2 lb. bag.
Bring friends and family together with festive gift boxes and pancakes.
A. NEW! SUNDAY SPREAD GIFT BOX $64.99
Gift-Boxed & Holiday-Ready Kick off your holiday mornings with flavor, fun, and family. This festive brunch box has everything you need for a crowdpleasing start. Inside you’ll find Blueberry Pancake Mix, Blueberry Syrup, Stoneground Cheddar Cheese Grits, Sausage Ball Mix and Old Forge Distillery’s Bloody Mary Mix, making it easy to create a delicious and memorable morning.
B. SMOKY MOUNTAIN CHRISTMAS MORNING $109.99
Gift-Boxed & Holiday-Ready This complete breakfast spread brings the joy of holiday mornings to your table. Share laughter, warmth, and homemade flavors with family and friends for a morning to remember. Includes Buttermilk Pancake Mix, Barrel-Aged Bourbon Maple Syrup, S’Mores Flavored Coffee, Old Fashioned Buttermilk Biscuit Mix, Cranberry Pear Jam, Peppered Gravy Mix, Cinnamon Swirl Bread Mix, and a Tin of Double Chocolate Cocoa.
C. OLD FORGE DISTILLERY BLOODY MARY MIX $11.99
Old Forge Distillery’s best-selling homemade Bloody Mary Mix is an entertaining must-have.
“Just like my grandmother used to make.” — Diana Waffles for breakfast. Or brunch. Or dinner.
A. NEW! PANCAKE BREAKFAST BOX $49.99
Gift-Boxed & Holiday-Ready Stack ‘em high! Our Pancake Breakfast Box includes a bag of our classic Buttermilk Pancake Mix, which only requires some milk, an egg, and a little bit of oil, oh, and a hot skillet! Included also is a bottle of our Pure Maple Syrup, our Peach Preserves, and Strawberry Preserves, both homemade and from our Heritage Collection of jams, jellies, and preserves.
$12.99
Blueberry, Butter Maple, Muscadine, Triple Berry, Cinnamon Maple, Strawberry, Raspberry, Pure Maple Syrup and Apple Butter
BREAKFAST JUST LIKE YOU REMEMBER
From the grits to the biscuits, this gift-boxed set brings the comforting flavors of The Old Mill Restaurant to your own holiday morning.
“My wife said it was her best Christmas gift. Thank you Old Mill.”
— Darrell
THE
Gift-Boxed & Holiday-Ready Bring home the flavors of a classic Old Mill Restaurant breakfast—just like you remember. From buttery biscuits to golden pancakes and warm syrup, this comforting collection makes any morning feel like a special occasion. Includes Buttermilk
“This will be the only pancake mix I get from now on.”— Quyen
A. NEW! THE PERFECT SPREAD $69.99 Gift-Boxed & Holiday-Ready To us, the perfect spread must hit all the flavors of sweet, tangy, spicy, and savory, and The Perfect Spread Box does just that! We’ve put together our Mild Pickled Okra, Red Mild Pepper Jelly, Cranberry Pepper Jelly, and Blackberry Preserves to accompany Roasted Garlic Cheese and Italian Beef Sausage that are served on The Best Darn Crackers. Add in some fresh berries, fruit, and nuts and you’ve just elevated this spread.
&
B. FRUIT BUTTERS AND FRUIT SPREADS Peach Butter $9.99, Apple Butter $9.99, Strawberry Fruit Spread $13.99, and Whole Blueberry Fruit Spread $13.99. Each sold separately.
C. HONEY BUTTERS $14.99 EACH Strawberry Pecan, Milk Chocolate Pecan, Orange Pecan, Amaretto Pecan, Cinnamon, Apple Spice Pecan and Cranberry Orange Pecan. Each sold separately.
D. NEW! PEPPER JELLIES BOX $34.99 Gift-Boxed
Holiday-Ready What’s spicy, sweet, and brings all the fun to a gathering? Our Pepper Jellies Box, that’s what! You get a four-pack of half-pint jars: Strawberry Jalapeno, Red Mild Pepper, Garlic Pepper, and Green Mild Pepper Mountain Jellies, all made right in our Farmhouse Kitchen.
SCAN FOR THE CHRISTMAS COOKIE RECIPE
MEET FRED, JAM MAKER Fred turns fresh, local fruit into small-batch jams, jellies, and fruit butters. Every jar is a taste of tradition and a reminder that the best things come from nearby.
SCAN TO SHOP JAMS, JELLIES & PRESERVES
A. CHRISTMAS JAM $14.99 Our top-selling holiday jam, made once a year in small batches from pears, plums, cranberries, oranges, and cinnamon. Festive, spiced, and naturally sweet, It’s Christmas in a jar.
B. HONEY $12.99-$34.99 Honey has always been one of our customers’ favorites. We offer a large selection from Bourbon Infused to Sourwood in a variety of sizes. Each sold separately.
C. CUSTOMER FAVORITES $8.99 EACH Triple Berry Jam, Strawberry Jalapeno Jelly, Apple Cinnamon Preserves, Green Mild Pepper Jelly, Pear, Muscadine Jelly and Crabapple Jelly.
D. NEW! TENNESSEE SIX-PACK $49.99 Gift-Boxed & Holiday-Ready What’s a Tennessee Six-Pack? It’s the top six preserves from our lineup! Made in our Farmhouse Kitchen in copper kettles by our skilled makers, because we think that’s the best way to do it. You’ll get half-pint jars of our Blueberry, Peach, Pear, Apple Cinnamon, Fig, and Wild Blackberry.
GRAINS, FLOURS & SPECIALTY BREADINGS
PANTRY TRADITIONS
Homestyle Broccoli
Soup Mix $12.99
Tomato Basil Soup Mix $11.99
WARM UP THE SEASON
Ready in under 30 minutes, our Signature Soup mixes need only water for a hearty, fresh-flavored meal your family will love.
A. SOUP SAMPLER $34.99 A customer favorite for gift-giving year after year. Our Soup Sampler includes our Signature Corn Chowder, Loaded Baked Potato, Creamy Vegetable, and Broccoli Cheddar mixes. Each package makes four 1-cup servings.
B. WINTER SOUP GIFT SET $39.99
Gift-Boxed & Holiday-Ready A hearty pair of our most popular soups to get you and your family through those cold winter days. Includes Corn Chowder Mix, Loaded Baked Potato Soup Mix and four freshly-baked Bread Bowls from our cafe.
C. CHOWDER & CORNBREAD SAMPLER $28.99
Gift-Boxed & Holiday-Ready Nothing says comfort like a warm bowl of chowder with a side of fresh cornbread. Includes our Signature Corn Chowder Mix and enough mix to bake a 10-inch skillet of golden cornbread. Hearty, simple, and perfect for serving eight.
D. SOUP MUG GIFT SET $88.99
Gift-Boxed & Holiday-Ready Handcrafted at Pigeon River Pottery, these handled soup mugs are perfect to enjoy your favorite soup on a cold night. Made by our team of skilled artisans and glazed in Farmhouse Frost. Each mug holds approximately 1.5-2 cups and stands about 2.5 inches tall. Set of two.
DOWN-SOUTH Pantry
Southern staples for your Christmas table. From breading and grits to Christmas Jam and pickles, it’s a pantry full of holiday tradition.
A. NEW! BEST SELLERS BOX $98.99 Gift-Boxed & Holiday-Ready We’ve collected together the items that our customers continue to order again and again. Here are our Top 10 customer favorites. You get Signature Corn Chowder, Loaded Baked Potato, and Broccoli Cheddar Soup Mixes, Triple Berry Jam, Peach Mountain Jelly, Crabapple Mountain Jelly, Self-Rising Yellow Cornmeal, Stone Ground White Grits, Old-Fashioned Buttermilk Biscuit Mix, and Buttermilk Pancake Mix.
FROM PAGE 14
A. Mini Cookbooks $9.99 Each
B. Classic Fried Chicken Breading $9.99
C. Pure Maple Syrup $14.99
D. Belgian Waffle Mix $10.99
E. Shrimp & Grits Starter Kit $6.99
F. Double Chocolate Hot Cocoa Mix $14.99
G. Mulling Spice $9.99
H. Maple Crystals $5.99
I. Cranberry Pear Jam $10.99
J. Banana Nut Muffin Mix $12.99
K. Double Chocolate Brownie Mix $10.99
L. Pecan Pie Mix $14.99
M. Ciders $9.99 Each
N. Salsas $12.99 Each
O. Christmas Jam & Pickles Gift Set $29.99
P. Sausage Ball Mix $9.99
Q. Bourbon Peach Preserves $8.99
“You simply add your favorite sausage (hot or mild), cream cheese, and shredded cheddar. Bake them up and watch them disappear!”
— Patricia
B. SAUSAGE BALL MIX $9.99 Southerners know that sausage ball appetizers are the perfect way to get any party started. Our Sausage Ball Mix makes preparing delicious, cheesy sausage balls easier than ever. You can even make them ahead and freeze them for convenience. A tasty treat at breakfast, brunch, or that special soiree!
C. NEW! WELL SEASONED KIT $16.99 Gift-Boxed & Holiday-Ready Bring authentic Southern flavor to every meal. This kit includes Cornbread Dressing Seasoning, Herb-Crusted Prime Rib Seasoning, and Roasted Veggie Seasoning—everything you need to keep your cooking perfectly seasoned.
Distinctive flavors, handmade treasures, and even a new cookbook from one of our own.
“I pick our Unbolted White Cornmeal, especially when used to make our Holiday Cornbread Dressing!” — Delmar SCAN TO GET OUR HOLIDAY CORNBREAD DRESSING RECIPE
“My pick is the Pumpkin Spice Pancake Mix, but made into muffins! They are irresistible!” — Chuck
Pumpkin Spice Pancake Mix $12.99
Whole Grain Steel Cut Oats $7.99/2 LB. C. 1830 Grind Unbolted White Cornmeal $7.99/2 LB., $14.99/5 LB.
Pumpernickel Flour $7.99/2 LB.
A. NEW! SEASONED IN APPALACHIA BY JIMMY PROFFITT $28 Filled with 75 cherished family recipes and stories of time-honored traditions, Seasoned in Appalachia takes you on a journey into the heart of the mountains. This debut cookbook by our own Jimmy Proffitt celebrates the food and stories that bring people together. We’re proud to support Jimmy, a member of The Old Mill family for 27 years. All copies are signed. Personalization is available when you preorder by phone. Releases October 28. Preorder by calling 877-653-6455 or order online after release.
B. WHITE C. BROWN HANDMADE POTTERY PUMPKIN $99.99/EACH
Handmade Pottery Pumpkin from Pigeon River Pottery. A timeless fall statement piece you’ll enjoy year after year. Each is unique in color and size, approximately 9 inches tall.
HOLIDAY BAKING
Bring festive warmth to your table with our signature mixes.
A. DOUBLE CHOCOLATE BROWNIE MIX $10.99 Made with natural ingredients, no artificial flavors or preservatives, plus real Dutch cocoa and semisweet chocolate chips. Just add two eggs and a stick of butter for rich, fudgy brownies in minutes. Yields one 8- or 9-inch pan.
B. BANANA NUT MUFFIN MIX $12.99 Enjoy the beloved banana nut muffins from The Old Mill Restaurant in your own kitchen! Our easy-touse mix requires just water and a mashed banana to whip up tender and flavorful muffins that are perfectly sweet. Makes approximately one dozen muffins.
C. PECAN PIE MIX $14.99 If you’ve ever tasted a bite of The Old Mill Restaurant’s famous pecan pie, you will understand why we put the pie into a mix that you can bake anytime you are ready. You’ll be amazed by the homemade taste! Makes one 9-inch pie.
D. CREAM CHEESE POUND CAKE MIX $9.99 We put the rich flavor of cream cheese and butter in this deliciously moist, dense cake. Our mix makes baking foolproof. People will beg for your secret recipe, and you’ll be pleased that your cake tastes homemade. (Bundt Size. Available in a 2 lb. bag.)
THE POTTERY HOUSE CAFE FAVORITE, AT HOME
Bring the taste of our Pottery House Cafe to your table. Golden fried chicken, tender waffles, and rich maple syrup make every brunch a true celebration. Perfect for lazy weekends, festive mornings, or anytime you want a little indulgence.
A. NEW! CHICKEN AND WAFFLE KIT
$39.99 Gift-Boxed & Holiday-Ready Includes, Classic Fried Chicken Breading, Belgian Waffle Mix, and a bottle of Pure Maple Syrup.
SCAN TO SHOP OUR HOLIDAY CATALOG ONLINE
B. NEW! SWEET BISCUIT BOX $39.99 Gift-Boxed & Holiday-Ready Is there anything better than a fresh, hot-from-the-oven biscuit with a drizzle of honey or a slathering of homemade Strawberry Preserves on it? We don’t think so! Our Old-Fashioned Buttermilk Biscuit Mix is simple and quick, so you’ll have those biscuits made and out of the oven before the coffee finishes brewing.
C. STATE FAIR FUNNEL CAKE MIX $12.99
Bring festive fun to your kitchen this season! Whip up crispy, golden funnel cakes in minutes, then sprinkle with powdered sugar or a dusting of cinnamon sugar for a sweet holiday treat everyone will love.
“Ordered funnel cake mixes for all the grands… it’s fun and yummy! Mema likes hers with 10x sugar, please!”
FROM OUR BAKERY
Fresh-baked breads, award-winning pies, and spirited creations
POTTERY HOUSE CAFE BREADS $9.99/EACH
Baked fresh each morning at our Pottery House Cafe and shipped Monday through Wednesday to ensure it arrives within two days, at peak freshness.
A. CINNAMON RAISIN PECAN
B. ONION RYE
C. SOURDOUGH
G. BREAD SAMPLER $29.99 Gift-Boxed & HolidayReady A holiday-ready trio of our most-loved breads, baked fresh at the Pottery House Cafe. Includes one full-size loaf each of Sourdough, Cinnamon Raisin Pecan, and Cranberry Walnut.
MEET THE MAKER
Lenin starts early, hand-shaping and baking breads that fill The Pottery House Cafe with irresistible aromas. Using grains milled just steps away at The Old Mill, every loaf is made with care, tradition, and a touch of home. For Lenin, sharing his bread with guests is the sweetest reward.
POTTERY HOUSE CAFE BREAD BAKER, LENIN
D. HONEY WHEAT
E. MULTI GRAIN
F. CRANBERRY WALNUT
THE PIES THAT MADE US FAMOUS!
A. THE OLD MILL RESTAURANT PECAN PIE $39.99 Gift-Boxed & Holiday-Ready People drive for miles to get a slice of this Southern legend. Chopped pecans and a perfect crust make every bite holiday heaven. Serves 6–8. B. POTTERY HOUSE CAFE CHOCOLATE PECAN PIE $39.99 Gift-Boxed & Holiday-Ready One of our most-loved pies is a customer obsession. We took the Southern classic and made it irresistible with a generous layer of
chocolate. Baked fresh daily in our Cafe. Serves 6–8. Baked fresh and loved for generations, these Southern favorites are perfect for your holiday table.
SWEET HOLIDAY MOMENTS
Old Mill Fudge is still made by hand in small batches using fresh, wholesome ingredients. Milk, butter, sugar, and more are combined to create sweet, smooth fudge so dense, rich, and creamy that you’ll wonder how you ever lived without it.
TREATS JUST LIKE YOU REMEMBER
From crisp toffee to cloudlike divinity, these old-fashioned favorites are made in small batches, right here at The Old Mill Candy Kitchen.
A. ENGLISH TOFFEE $29.99 Gift-Boxed & Holiday-Ready
Made in small batches by our Old Mill Candy Kitchen confectioners. Our English Toffee is hand-poured, topped with chocolate and chopped almonds, then hand-broken into generous pieces. 1 LB.
B. PEPPERMINT BARK $19.99 Gift-Boxed & Holiday-Ready Handmade in The Old Mill Candy Kitchen. Layers of rich chocolate and crushed peppermint create a crisp, festive holiday treat. 1 LB.
C. DIVINITY GIFT BOX $11.99 Gift-Boxed & Holiday-Ready Handmade in The Old Mill Candy Kitchen. Fluffy divinity blended with diced pecans and topped with a whole pecan. 8 pieces.
D. PECAN LOGS $34.99 Gift-Boxed & Holiday-Ready Hand-rolled nougat dipped in caramel and coated in premium pecans, made in The Old Mill Candy Kitchen. Four Logs.
E. FUDGE SAMPLER GIFT TIN $29.99 Gift-Boxed & Holiday-Ready Rich fudge made with real butter and cream in The Old Mill Candy Kitchen. Includes Chocolate, Cookies & Cream, Chocolate Walnut, and Peanut Butter (¼ LB. each).
F. ASSORTED BEAR PAWS GIFT BOX $32.99
Gift-Boxed & Holiday-Ready Caramel poured over fresh pecans and covered in milk, dark, and white chocolate, made in The Old Mill Candy Kitchen. Includes 2 of each.
Bear paws, buckeyes, and hand-dipped chocolates—crafted for giving, gathering, and a little indulgence along the way.
MEET THE MAKER
CANDY MAKER, LUKE
Luke turns sugar, cream, and chocolate into irresistible treats at The Old Mill Candy Kitchen. His house-made caramel, cooked in a traditional copper kettle, fills our famous Bear Paws and Chocolate Bears, bringing skill, soul, and a taste of tradition to every bite.
SALT WATER TAFFY
With 100-year-old taffy machines, we make a variety of flavors, so there’s something for everyone.
A. TAFFY BOX $14.99 A favorite treat, our salt water taffy is just the right size for a stocking. Made on our century-old taffy pulling and wrapping machines, sweet and flavorful taffy comes assorted in a gift box. (1 lb.)
TAFFY MAKER, JOSE
Jose’s taffy is part candy, part performance. Inside The Old Mill Candy Kitchen, he uses century-old machines and serious skill to pull, twist, and wrap each piece by hand. The show draws a crowd. The taste brings them back.
B. BRITTLE SAMPLER GIFT SET $39.99
Gift-Boxed & Holiday-Ready Our brittle is made with sugar, butter, and fresh cream, and hand stirred in copper kettles, as we pour in the nuts. This collection includes 12 oz. of each Peanut, Pecan, and Cashew Brittle.
C. SMOKY MOUNTAIN SWEET SAMPLER $44.99
Gift-Boxed & Holiday-Ready Send a little sweetness from the Smoky Mountains (or just grab some up for yourself!) with this collection of confections from our Old Mill Candy Kitchen. Handmade in-house with the freshest ingredients, you get Pecan Clusters, Bourbon Pecans, Toffee, (Milk, White, and Dark Chocolate) Bear Paws, and Chocolate Covered Peanuts.
SCAN TO SHOP MORE CHOCOLATES & CANDY
DOGWOOD GLAZE The blossoms of dogwood trees are sure signs of springtime in the Smokies. Their rich and creamy white flowers, burnished with
EVERY SIP MADE SPECIAL
Gifts crafted to last, honoring those who make, give, and celebrate.
A. TALL TUMBLER $29.99 The preferred tumbler for iced tea around here, which of course is nice and sweet! Perfect for a warm beverage as well. Single tumbler, holding approximately 16 ounces. Glazed in Flowering Dogwood.
B. CRAFTER’S MUG SET $59.99 This handcrafted mug holds a generous 12 ounces of your favorite hot beverage. Its Smoky Mountain Autumn glaze features vibrant reds, capturing the essence of fall and carrying the warmth into the holiday season.
C. FLOWERING DOGWOOD POTTER’S MUG PAIR 59.99
Made with love by our Pigeon River Pottery artisans, these 12-ounce mugs are perfect for savoring your favorite beverage.
D. FLOWERING DOGWOOD E. LECONTE MOUNTAIN RIDGE STEMLESS WINE GOBLET SET $54.99 Gift-Boxed & Holiday-Ready
Indulge in a touch of handcrafted luxury with our Stemless Wine Goblets. Each 8-ounce goblet is meticulously handmade by local artisans in our Pigeon River Pottery studio.
MEET THE MAKER
PIGEON RIVER POTTERY POTTER, JASON
At Pigeon River Pottery, Jason gives Tennessee clay a new story with every turn of the wheel. His hands shape more than mugs, dinnerware, and pottery candles— they shape traditions meant to be gathered around the table, passed down, and used every day.
175 Old Mill Avenue
Pigeon Forge, TN 37863
OLD MILL GIFT CARD The perfect gift, every time. Old Mill Gift Cards can be used at the Old Mill Restaurant or Pottery House Cafe, or any of our shops. No expiration, no fees.
FROM OUR TABLE $39.99 At The Old Mill Restaurant, every hearty meal begins with our Signature Corn Chowder and a basket of corn fritters served with maple butter. Now you can share that same welcoming warmth at home with our set, complete with Corn Chowder Mix, Fritter Mix, and Maple Crystals.
MORE WAYS TO SHOP
Shop the catalog using the QR Code, visit old-mill.com, or call 877-653-6455. You’ll also find even more gifts and seasonal favorites online.
GATHER, GIFT, AND SAVOR THE SEASON
From The Old Mill Restaurant favorites to our Gift Card, there’s something special for everyone on your list.
